Point/Counterpoint
In this edition, Tracy will be making the point and I will be making the counterpoint. Start by reading her point.
Here is my counterpoint:
I think it's safe to say that most people think of themselves as honest people. Unless you're Natalie Portman in Garden State and lying is akin to a nervous tick, you will (for the most part) tell the truth about things.
Most reasons for lying (dishonesty) can be lumped into two categories: (1) you are trying to protect yourself -or- (2) you are trying to avoid hurting someone else's feelings. (I guess there's also a third reason to lie, which would be humor... but that's not pertinent to the discussion at hand.)
I think our culture generally assumes that a person will tell the truth up until the point that the truth hurts them or hurts someone else in some way. Saying that I'm an honest person carries about as much weight as saying I'm a good person: it means I lie, but only when it's socially acceptable.
This creates a problem, because calling someone who always tells the truth "honest" is no longer good enough. Hence the identifier brutally honest: someone who always tells the truth, even when the truth hurts.
If I'm a brutally honest person, that doesn't mean that everything I say is brutal or painful in some way. Sometimes the truth hurts, but sometimes it's just the truth. The brutal part is just an explanation of the lengths that I will go to out of my value for honesty. I will go all out.
It's kind of like me referring to T.J. Ford as one of the best basketball players in University of Texas history. T.J. is a basketball player in University of Texas history, and the degree to which he played makes him one of the best.
Brutal honesty is a state of being rather than an identifier of a specific situation. In that way it is an inseparable term of characterization. Need I remind you all that a house divided cannot stand? Take brutal and separate it from honesty and you have someone that is mean for no reason, and honest when they should be... nothing more.
Also, I win.